Evnroll vs Scotty Cameron Putters: Head To Head Comparison

Choosing between Evnroll and Scotty Cameron is one of the most common debates you’ll find on golf forums and in pro shop fitting bays. Both brands command premium prices and loyal followings, but they deliver performance through fundamentally different approaches.

Our staff of experts, including PGA Tour Professional John VanDerLaan, breaks down the differences between EvnRoll putters and Scotty Cameron putters so that you can decide which one is right for you.

Brand Background: Evnroll and Scotty Cameron in context

Understanding each brand’s philosophy helps explain how their putters perform and feel on the course.

Scotty Cameron built his reputation starting in the early 1990s as a boutique putter maker before partnering with Titleist in 1994. The brand now operates under the Acushnet umbrella alongside Titleist, FootJoy, Vokey Design, and Pinnacle. Scotty’s presence on the PGA Tour is undeniable—Newport and Newport 2 style blades have contributed to multiple major championship wins since the late 1990s, cementing the “tour-proven” image that many players love.

Evnroll took a different path. Founded by Guerin Rife in Carlsbad, California around 2015-2016, the brand was built around “Sweet Face” technology first patented in the mid-2010s. Unlike Scotty Cameron, Evnroll remains independent and positions itself as an innovation-driven alternative focused specifically on roll consistency and distance control. Evnroll also designed and manufacture a heavy, counterbalanced grip called the Gravity Grip. Many players find they have much more control when using the Gravity Grip. 

The contrast is clear:

• Scotty Cameron = heritage, craftsmanship, tour cachet
• Evnroll = technology, consistency, engineering-driven performance

Design philosophy and technology

Though both brands produce 100% milled putters, they approach performance in fundamentally different ways.

Scotty Cameron’s approach

Scotty Cameron models like the Super Select Newport 2 and Super Select Newport + feature solid 303 stainless steel construction with meticulous attention to traditional milling patterns. Key design elements include:

• Multimaterial sole plates and tungsten weights in select heads for stability
• Refined shapes with sleek toplines that appeal to purists
• Traditional face milling prioritizing feel over aggressive groove technology
• The Special Select Squareback 2 blends blade aesthetics with a wider body and plumbing neck for added stability

Evnroll’s approach

Evnroll’s “Sweet Face” technology represents a different philosophy entirely. Models like the ER2 and Neo Classic ER2 feature variable groove spacing and depth across the face. This design means:

• Off-center strikes roll similar distances to center hits
• Ball tracks back toward the intended line on mishits
• Precise 303 stainless milling with a more modern visual identity
• Bold alignment lines and thicker toplines on some models prioritize performance over classic looks

The core contrast comes down to this: Scotty Cameron emphasizes pure milled feel and shape refinement, while Evnroll focuses on face-technology-driven performance and forgiveness.

Scotty Cameron putters are basically the “Cadillac” of the golfing/putting world. They are the luxury brand against which all other entries are measured. Scotty uses top-end materials and emphasize style as much as playability, and are coveted equally for both.

With a Cameron putter you are going to see an emphasis on 100% CNC milling except on more elaborate designs that use multiple materials. This is the technology that broke Scotty into the industry and allowed him to make his mark on TOUR. Meanwhile, several other high-dollar putter companies have created 100% CNC-milled german steel putters, but they don’t quite have the cachet of the Scotty Cameron brand.

RELATED: Why Are Scotty Cameron Putters So Expensive?

Feel, sound and feedback

For many golfers, feel and sound matter as much as measurable performance. This is where personal preference plays a major role.

Scotty Cameron feel profile

Scotty Cameron putters typically deliver a soft-but-solid sensation with a muted “click” at impact. The Super Select Newport 2 and Squareback 2 exemplify this characteristic. Contributing factors include:

• Stainless steel heads with interchangeable sole weights

• Milled face patterns refined over decades

• Thinner toplines and compact face heights that enhance perceived precision at address

Many players equate this precision at address with better feel and more confidence over the ball.

Evnroll feel profile

Evnroll’s feel varies across models but generally sits between soft and firm depending on groove depth. User feedback suggests:

• Some ER models produce a slightly higher-pitched sound compared to the more muted TaylorMade Spider or certain Scotty Camerons

• The variable groove design creates a feel some describe as “softer” than traditional milled faces

• Players who switched from TaylorMade Spider or Scotty to Evnroll ER2 reported better roll and distance control, even if they initially preferred the sound of their old putter

Recommendation: Test both putters in person. Sound and feel preference is highly individual—neither brand is objectively “better” here. What matters is which one makes you feel more confident standing over your putts.

Performance and Forgiveness

We had our staff test both the Evnroll putters and the Scotty Cameron putters for performance and forgiveness. The results came down to who was doing the testing.

PGA Tour professional, John VanDerLaan ranked the Scotty Camerons to be the top performing putters.

High handicappers ranked the EvnRoll putters to be more forgiving and better performing.

Each tester ranked the putters on a scale of 1-10. You can see the results below.