Best Putters For High Handicappers(2024)The Complete Guide

Written by Michael VanDerLaan 

Updated

*We may earn revenue from the products available on this site and participate in affiliate programs.

Putting is the greatest determining factor of any player’s score. Whether you are a beginner or a pro, you can expect putting to take up about 40% of your strokes.

Because of this, we felt the need to review the best putters for high handicappers in order to help you discover the club that will help you bring your scores down and your enjoyment up.

Our FAvorite

Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter

Odyssey golf white hot OG

Classic Mallet

Odyssey Golf Triple Track 2 Ball Putter

odyssey Golf triple track two ball

Best Budget Option

Lazrus Premium Black Golf Putter

Lazrus Premium Black Golf Putter

Best Putters for High Handicappers At A Glance

Best Mallet Putters For High Handicappers

Odyssey Golf Eleven Triple Track Putter

The Odyssey 11 Triple Track is an ideal mallet putter for high handicappers who struggle with alignment on the greens. This solid, one piece putter head features a main red flange line the runs perpendicular to the face along with 2 blue lines and a white stripe that all add extra visual aids.

What we love most about the this mallet putter is the forgiveness. Due to the bulk that Odyssey added to the head of the putter, the Moment of Inertia reading is off the charts. Essentially, if you hit a ball off the heel or toe, you still have a really good chance at hitting your start line with good speed.

What We Like

  • We love the alignment lines on this putter. The entire thing is designed to help you square up to your start line
  • This is one of the most forgiving putters we have ever tested
  • The face insert provides a soft feel without impacting speed control
  • Odyssey carries a reputation of excellence with putters

What We Don't Like

  • Some people do not like the excessive alignment aids on the putter head
  • The putter head is particularly large and heavy, making it feel clunky to some players

When it comes to high handicap players, all of the main struggles with putting tend to stem from poor contact. With the Odyssey 11 Triple Track, not only will you have an easier time lining up to your putts, you will also see amazing consistency even on off center strikes!

Some people may not love the aesthetic of this putter, but several features related to overall performance make it a great choice for high handicappers. 


Taylormade Spider X Putter

The Spider is one of the flagship model putters from Taylormade and is an incredibly popular mallet putter in both the professional and amateur games. Countless players trust the combination of alignment aid and forgiveness that the putter head offers. 

We have used this mallet putter on and off over the last few years, and have found that it performs extremely well on smoother greens. On slower, bumpier greens, it is a little hard to control. 

It sounds crazy, but the reason for this is because the Spider rolls the ball too well. On greens with inconsistencies, the ball is more likely to be impacted by an unfortunate bounce. If the biggest complaint about a putter is that it rolls the ball too well, it's safe to say it is a fantastic option!

What We Like

  • This putter is simple, good looking, and highly forgiving
  • Trusted by some of the best players in the world
  • Backed by Taylormade's reputation for excellence

What We Don't Like

  • Pricey
  • Some players don't like mallets

The Taylormade Spider does not disappoint, period. You will love how consistent it is on both well struck putts and mishits. The milling on the face helps the ball come off smooth, making it incredibly easy to hit putts on line with consistent speed. 

That is why you will see it in the bags of some of the best putters in the world on the PGA Tour.

The bottom line - if you want the most forgiving, consistent putter, the Taylormade Spider is for you.

RELATED: 11 Most Forgiving Putters With Expert Reviews


Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter

If you have watched Justin Thomas play golf over the years, this putter should be familiar to you. Justin has had a borderline Hall of Fame career already, and the majority of it has been with a Scotty Cameron Titleist Phantom X 5.5 in his bag.

Scotty Cameron is well known as the peak of putter craftsmanship and cutting edge technology. This putter lives up to that standard. Made with top quality stainless steel, with changeable weights to help you fit the putter to your game, as well as a beautifully defined flange line and exceptional perimeter weighting, the Phantom X 5.5 is a high performance putter that is sure to please even the players who prefer a blade!

What We Like

  • Scotty Cameron putters are the best, hands down
  • This putter provides exceptional feel and forgiveness
  • We love how balanced and well-made the Phantom X 5.5 is

What We Don't Like

  • Very pricey

Scotty Cameron putters have it all. The reputation, the quality, the innovation. But they also have the price tag to go with it. While there is no better putter brand than Scotty Cameron, and the Phantom X 5.5 is about as close to perfect as a putter can get, it is price prohibitive for a lot of people. It is for this reason that it is not our favorite.

RELATED: Kirkland Putter vs Scotty Cameron


Odyssey Golf Triple Track 2 Ball Putter

The two ball putter is a long time favorite of players who prefer the mallet putter design. It is simple, elegant, and offers some of the feel of a blade putter while adding the alignment lines and forgiveness benefits of a mallet. 

By adding their proprietary triple track design, Odyssey has made the two ball even better. You will absolutely know when you are lined up properly to your putts, meaning you will absolutely become more consistent on the greens.

What We Like

  • We love the feel of the ball coming off the face of this putter. It is firm, yet controlled
  • Between the triple track and two ball alignment aids, you can be confident that you are lined up well
  • Odyssey is the most trusted putter brand across all levels of golf

What We Don't Like

  • Some golfers cannot get past the look of the putter
  • High forgiveness takes away from overall feedback off the face

Some golfers find that the aesthetics of the Triple Track Two Ball are a lot to take in, and prefer a putter with a little less going on, but I love the fantastic alignment tools on this mallet putter. I am here to tell you that, if you struggle with club face alignment, there is no better putter for you. 


Best Blade Putters For High Handicappers

Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter

The Odyssey White Hot series has been a staple at the top of putter rankings for decades. We simply could not put together a list of the top putters without including this installment of that family that features the original characteristics of the putter with some newer tech added in. 

The insert in the face of the White Hot OG gives this putter a soft feel, while the precision milling around the edges combined with enhanced weight distribution provide an out of this world feel. This is a putter that competes with any other blade, oftentimes at a fraction of the price. 

RELATED: Best Center Shafted Putters – With Expert Reviews

What We Like

  • Simple and classic design
  • Looks very similar to the original White Hot series
  • Backed by decades of outstanding reputation from Odyssey

What We Don't Like

  • Not very forgiving

There is a reason that countless professional golfers trust Odyssey, and it's not because they are getting paid to do it. The White Hot OG takes Odyssey right back to the roots that built their reputation, and is one of the most reliable putters out there right now. 

If you want a putter that will perform day after day without breaking the bank, the White Hot OG is for you. 


EvnRoll ER2 Putter

Evnroll putters have become known in the last few years for just how consistent they are and how goof they feel. The ER2 model is their blade that is designed for the traditionalists of the game.

Evnroll gets its name from what they call Sweetface Technology, which essentially means that they have tried to make the sweet spot as big as possible. Essentially, any putt that is struck on the grooves of the putter face will feel solid, meaning more putts roll the same way!

RELATED: Evnroll vs Scotty Cameron Putters: Head To Head Comparison

What We Like

  • A huge sweet spot makes for more solid feeling putts
  • You will be amazed with the consistency of the roll off the putter face
  • Evnroll is an up and coming brand that is trusted by some of the world's best players

What We Don't Like

  • Not a lot of alignment aids
  • Less forgiving than some other putters for extreme mishits

While not the most forgiving putter in the world, the Evnroll ER2 will provide you with a bigger sweet spot that feels fantastic and will help you immensely with both speed control and consistency. We have found over hours of testing that the ER2 is by far the best feeling blade putter on the market for high handicappers. 


Most Technology: PXG 0211 Putter  

PXG 0211 Putter

PXG broke onto the golf club scene around the same time that Nike phased out, and they could not have produces a better run of clubs to capitalize. Since then, there have been a number of solid additions to their lineup, including the 0211 putter. 

Precision cross milling on the face helps the ball launch and roll with extreme consistency, ensuring minimal skid. PXG also uses only the highest quality materials and production processes to ensure that every club comes off the line above their extremely high standards. 

What We Like

  • We love how simple this putter is aesthetically
  • PXG is known for having some of the highest quality materials and designs
  • The feel off the face of the 0211 is exceptional

What We Don't Like

  • Pricey

PXG does not offer flashy aesthetics, or gimmicky marketing schemes. They produce high quality clubs designed to perform. The 0211 putter does just that. You will love the feel of this modern blade, and you will love the way the ball rolls even more. The only real downside is the price premium attached to PXG clubs.


Cleveland Golf Huntington Beach Soft #4 Putter

Here is a club that combines the traditions of a true blade putter with some of the more modern characteristics. The Soft #4 is a simple, well built putter with no bells and whistles. Cleveland Golf has a history of high quality, reliable equipment and this putter is no different.

One of our favorite things on this putter is the variable milling on the face that helps create a more consistent roll no matter how you strike the putt. Even for more severe toe and heel strikes, you will notice that the ball comes off relatively the same!

What We Like

  • We love how simple the design of this putter is
  • Variable milling on the face of the putter lends a very good feel

What We Don't Like

  • Cleveland Golf is not known for their putters

Forget about all the flashy features meant to get your attention with the Huntington Beach series. Cleveland Golf has rolled out a line of simple, aesthetically pleasing, solid feeling putters that you can rely on time after time. If you have a preference for a blade putter, try the number 4 model!


Lazrus Premium Black Golf Putter

Just like their premium irons, Lazrus Golf has produced a putter that tops the charts for anyone shopping on a budget. 

We love the contrast offered by the black coloration of this putter that provides solid feel, effective alignment aid, and lots of forgiveness. Other than the blue accents, there is not much about this putter we don't love!

What We Like

  • This is a high quality putter at an affordable price point
  • We love the compact and innovative design that provides a high level of forgiveness
  • We love the alignment aid. It is simple and is easy to use
  • Very affordable

What We Don't Like

  • Not a mainstream brand
  • Blue accents are different and can be hard to adjust to

For those whose goal is to balance cost, performance, feel, and quality, the Premium Black Putter from Lazrus is the perfect place to start. There are no fancy features or a long history of success, but this family owned American company does not cut corners when it comes to quality and design. If you are looking for a cheap putter that is great for high handicappers, this is your best bet.


Best Value: PGM Golf Putter

PGM Golf Putter

This putter from PGM is the epitome of an affordable alternative. It offers a soft but still solid feeling insert to help any golfer with more refined feel. 

PGM's putter is a very simple blade, although the contrast of the black head to the white insert gives it an added feel of value. The contrast is a fantastic alternative alignment aid. 

What We Like

  • The white face contrasted to the black head of this putter is a great tool for better alignment
  • The face insert feels really good on all types of greens
  • Incredibly affordable

What We Don't Like

  • You get what you pay for. This putter is certainly not the most high quality option out there

While not the most high quality or high status putter, PGM offers the perfect option for beginners and high handicappers. At a price point that is less than the average dozen golf balls, you can feel good knowing you didn't break the bank on your putter. Maybe even use your savings on lessons to help you play better golf!


Putter Buying Guide For High Handicappers

Below are all of the features and characteristics you are going to want to consider when looking for a new putter. These are based both on personal preference and personal fit, so don’t be afraid to mix and match as you are testing out putters.

Type Of Putter

This refers to the club head. The two major types are mallet and blade putters, although there are others that roughly fall into one of these categories. Understanding what type of putter is best for you is a great way to start putting better.

RELATED: Best Putting Drills To Make You A Better Putter

Mallet

Mallet style putter

Mallet putters are the ones with more substance to them. Everything from Brian Harmon’s spaceship of a putter to the more subtle Taylormade Spyder to some of the pronged options are all considered to be mallets. 

A mallet putter typically provides 2 main benefits:

  1. More weight in the back and edges of the putter head creates more forgiveness and a higher moment of inertia. This means there is a lower priority on hitting the center of the club face perfectly every time.
  2. With an extended back flange, it is usually easier to align mallet putters properly. This is a great bonus for your consistency.

These advantages typically make mallet putters a good choice for high handicappers. Having said that, there are golfers who simply prefer the look and feel of a blade. For those people, there are other unique advantages.

RELATED: Bettinardi vs Scotty Cameron Putters: Which Is Better And Why

Blade

Blade style putter

Blade putters are a more traditional approach to the shortest club in the bag. These are the putters with little to no flange on the back side of the club head. Most famous among them is them in terms of golf history is the bullseye putter. Contrary to popular belief, this was a putter made by Titleist, not Ping.

RELATED: Scotty Cameron Newport vs Newport 2 Putters: What's The Difference?

But what are the advantages of a blade? Here are the major ones you should know:

  1. Less perimeter weighting allows for more feedback. Since there is less overall forgiveness, blade putters will allow you to feel your misses more precisely. This also allows you to make the proper adjustments to be more consistent.
  2. Because of their lack of forgiveness, blades are a double edged sword of teaching you to be more consistent, while also punishing you more on your bad putts. If you can learn to hit the center of the club face every time, you are more likely to be a great putter with a blade. 

The best putters on tour trust both blade and mallet putters. Each one has its pros and cons, but the most important thing to discover is which works best for you!

RELATED: Blade vs Mallet Putter

Length Of Putter

The length of the putter you use typically depends on a few factors:

  • Your height - it stands to reason that, on average, a taller person will need a longer putter while someone shorter will need a shorter putter.
  • Putting setup - things like a wider stance and more bend at the hips will bring your hands closer to the ground and ultimately are suited better for a shorter putter versus a setup that is narrower and more upright.
  • Putting style - this is discussed more below, but there are different styles of putting that require different lengths of putter.

Putting Style

While your biological makeup (height, proportions, arm and leg length) are a major determinant to the length of your putter, putting style can be just as influential.

There are a number of putting styles that require specific types of putters. These include:

Broomstick with traditional grip
Armlock Traditional Putting Grip Style
Reverse Overlap Putting Grip
  • The broomstick - while anchoring the putter has been banned for the last several years, some players still find success in the broomstick method. This is the one you see from Bernhard Langer and Adam Scott that involves holding the putter to your chest and using that as the focal point of your movement. Broomstick putters are typically around 50 inches long, far longer than the 32-36 inch traditional putters.
  • Armlock - this is the putting style used by Will Zalatoris and Matt Kuchar, where the putter grip is anchored to your forearm. These putters are typically around 42 inches long and have more actual loft than a traditional putter. NOTE - anchoring the putter to your forearm BELOW THE ELBOW is legal in all forms of competition.
  • Counterbalance - these putters look similar to armlock putters, except they are not designed to forward press the way that armlock putters are. Counterbalance simply means there is added weight in the butt end of the club,which changes how the putter weight feels and is designed to help you release the club. This putting style was a popular point of conversation around Rickie Fowler and Wyndham Clark at the 2023 US Open. 

There are also a number of putting grip styles that may require changes to the putter that best fits you. You can check out our in depth analysis of the most popular putting grip styles if you are not sure which one you use. 

Putter Grip

Choose a putter grip that matches your needs

Putter grip refers to the actual piece of rubber on the club, rather than the putting grip styles we mentioned above. Again, depending on how you hold the club, there might be a specific putter grip that will work best for you.

We recommend you familiarize yourself with the best putter grips for your game, and try to match your putting grip style to the grip you put on the club. 

RELATED: Best Counterbalanced Putters And Grips With Reviews

Face Loft

Everyone’s stroke is different, so there is no such thing as “correct” loft for a putter. While most traditional putters sit around 3 degrees, the range is from 0 all the way up to 6 or 7 on the armlock putters. 

A good rule of thumb to get you on the right track is: the more forward press or shaft lean you use, the more loft your putter should have. 

Face Inserts

Face insert in a Scotty Cameron putter

Face inserts are a more modern piece of technology that helps players to further personalize their putter. Simply put, a face insert in a putter is a piece of material that changes the firmness and milling of the point of contact. You can buy putters with inserts that either make a putter much softer, or even firmer, depending on your personal feels.

Typically, a soft face is good for fast greens and players who have fast, aggressive strokes, while a firm face plays well on slow greens and for players with a more deliberate motion.

Aiming Aids

Different putter have different alignment aids

One of the major advantages of mallet putters, aiming aids are simply a characteristic of putters that helps you hit your start line more frequently. Most putters have some form of aiming aid - either a top line, a flange line, balls on the back flange, or some combination. The extended back flange of mallet putters allows for additional aiming aids, creating a more complete optical assistance for the player to get set up properly.

Weight Distribution

The way weight is distributed in a putter usually refers to the amount of “toe hang” that a putter has. If you balance your putter on your open palm and let it sit naturally, the club head is going to do one of a few things:

  • Face balance refers to a putter whose face aims at the sky when sitting naturally.
  • Some toe hang means the toe of your putter sits lower than the heel, usually on a 30, 45, or 60 degree angle.
  • Full toe hang refers to a putter whose head is perpendicular to the ground, with the heel pointed straight to the sky. 

A common concept in putting is that the amount of toe hang on your putter should correlate to the amount of arc in your stroke. A straight back, straight through stroke should be paired with a face balanced putter, while a stroke with a lot of arc should use a putter with full toe hang.

Feel

Finding the best putter for your game is sure to improve your feel

One feature of putters that is entirely based on personal preference is feel. This refers to everything from swing weight to the feel of the ball hitting the face to the way the putter feels in your hands. 

The only way to really know what you are looking for is to test some putters out, and maybe even ask your local professional for the specs on the ones you like. You can then take those pieces of information and find a putter that matches your specs and also fits your preferences of looks and putting style.

One key to feel is practice and consistency. We find that hitting a few putts every day on our Perfect Practice Putting Mat helps to develop day to day feel.

Price

Jim Furyk is famous for shooting 58 with an off the rack putter that he bought for less than $100. That’s not to say this is the solution for everyone, but it makes some people wonder if expensive putters are worth it.

Price is an important factor in everything in life. Finding a putter that fits your budget can be a challenge, but that is why we included some budget putters, as well as a number of putters that fall somewhere in the middle of the price spectrum. One great thing about buying a budget putter is that you can spend you savings on training aids like the Pelz Putting Tutor or the Eyeline Putting Mirror!

If you are looking for a putter you can trust, and you intend to use it for the long term, don’t be afraid to spend a little more. Your scores will thank you!

RELATED: Best Putter For The Money - Expert Reviews

Final Thoughts

Putting is often the make or break piece of the game of golf that can either help you to love the game, or never want to play again. Finding a putter that you love and can rely on is the first step to making more putts and having more fun. Just ask Danielle Kang, who travels with her putter in a rifle case just in case the rest of her clubs are lost by an airline!

Finding the perfect putter can be a difficult task. Between the different styles of putter, knowing what specs to look for, understanding your putting stroke, and factoring in all of the other characteristics of a putter can be daunting. 

Our hope is that we have pointed you in the right direction, and that you find the putter that you can rely on in every clutch situation down the road. We filtered through, tested, eliminated, and scrutinized some of the most talked about putters on the market in order to compile our list of the best putters for high handicappers, and we are confident that you will love one of them!

RELATED: Perfect Practice Putting Mat Review

Photo of author

Michael VanDerLaan

Michael is an Associate Editor here at Golf Gear Advisor. He is a playing professional with a passion for finding the best equipment through product testing and evaluation. He has an intimate knowledge of the golf swing and a very effective way of communicating his knowledge to those that are interested in learning more. As an Associate Editor at Golf Gear Advisor, Michael shares his knowledge about the golf swing, fitness and finding the right equipment for your game.

Leave a Comment